1. Benefits of ADU in the garage
Use of existing infrastructure
The biggest advantage of creating an ADU in a garage is using an existing framework. The foundation, walls, and ceiling are pre-built, so you only have to focus on the interior work. This saves time and resources. Using an existing infrastructure also means that you won’t have to face major construction challenges.
The advantage of being close to home
The garage is located near the main house, making it easy for people living in ADU to share amenities. Family members or tenants can easily use the services of the main house, such as Wi-Fi or water. Moreover, the proximity also increases security. If the elders of the house live there, it becomes easier to take care of them.
Less outdoor work is needed
The garage may already have electricity, water and drainage systems in place. This reduces construction time and you don’t need to build new pipelines or connections. In addition, the existing garage doors and windows are easy to incorporate into the ADI.
2. Disadvantages of ADU in garages
There is a limited space
The biggest disadvantage of building an ADU in a garage is the lack of space. Garages are usually between 200-400 square feet, which may not be enough for a large family. If you need more bedrooms or a bigger kitchen, then this option may not be right for you.
Parking problem
Converting a garage to an ADU means you will run out of parking space. If you already have problems with parking on the street, this option can become even more difficult.
Lack of natural light
Garages have fewer or fewer windows, which can lead to a lack of natural light inside. This problem can make the atmosphere of ADU a little nostalgic. However, this problem can be overcome by adding windows and skylights, but it will be an additional expense.
3. Advantages of Backyard ADU
Independent and separate space
Creating an ADU in the backyard provides a free and separate space. It is ideal for those who want more privacy. It is more attractive to renters as they experience distance from the main house.
Experience the natural environment
Creating an ADU in the backyard allows you to enjoy the natural environment more. If you have greenery in your backyard, those living in ADU get the benefit. This place is also suitable for children’s play or pets.
No flexibility in design
Backyard ADU gives you more options in terms of design. You can decide its size, layout and furniture according to your needs and desires. You can even add a small garden, deck, or patio, which makes ADU even more appealing.
4. Disadvantages of Backyard ADU
More Construction Tasks
New construction is required to build a backyard ADU. You have to put new foundations, build walls and put up roofs. This can increase the time and cost of construction.
Away from home
The backyard ADU takes place away from the main house, which can make the amenities a little difficult to access. If you have to use main house services, such as internet or electricity, there may be additional work and expense involved.
External Maintenance
After making ADUs in the backyard, it becomes necessary to take care of the exteriors. Cleaning, painting and gardening have to be done from time to time. It can demand more effort and attention in the long term.
5. Comparison of Maintenance and Repair
There is a difference in the maintenance of both garage and backyard ADUs. Garage ADUs need internal maintenance, while backyard ADUs also need to take care of the exteriors.
Garage ADUs already have power and water pipelines in place, making repairs easy. At the same time, new pipelines and connections need to be built in the backyard ADU, which can take time and effort. In addition, the backyard ADU also includes gardening and exterior cleaning.
6. Usage and Experience of Facilities
The garage ADU is close to the main house, making it easy to share the house’s amenities. Renters or family members may feel more connected with the main house.
On the other hand, there is an experience of privacy in the backyard ADU. It is in a different place, where the people living feel free. This option is suitable for families or individuals who want more autonomy.
7. Key points for decision-making
There are a few things to consider to make the right choice between garage and backyard ADUs.
Availability of space
How much space do you have and what kind of space do you have? If there is more free space in the backyard then backyard ADU can be a better option.
Intended Use
How do you want to use ADU? If it’s renting, a backyard ADU may be more suitable. If it’s to make for the family, Garage ADU might be better.
Long Term Plan
What are your long-term plans? If you want to make changes in the future, backyard ADUs have more flexibility.
Both garage and backyard ADUs have their own advantages and disadvantages. Garage ADU may be fast and simple, but it comes with limited space and a lack of natural light. Backyard ADU offers freedom and flexibility in design, but requires more construction work and maintenance. The mainstay of your decision should be the situation of your home, needs, and long-term planning. By choosing the right option, you can make your home more useful and attractive.
FAQs
The lack of natural light can be overcome by adding windows or installing skylights. Also, use light colors and good artificial light.
Open and practical design is best for backyard ADUs. Include large windows and sliding doors for natural light and ventilation.
Yes, maintenance is usually easy in garage ADUs. Using pre-existing power and water facilities saves time and effort in repairs.
Backyard ADUs require foundations, walls, roofs, electricity, and new water lines. Along with this, external maintenance and natural space care are also necessary.